As a large dairy operation, we are constantly seeking new skid steers to improve our efficiency. Recently, a local CAT representative visited us with some information that piqued our interest. In our area, it's rare to see a CAT skid steer on a dairy farm. The representative explained that this may be due to a lack of sales efforts targeting farmers and the misconception that CAT skid steers are expensive. Our current skid steers are mostly New Holland, Case, Bobcat, and John Deere models, but we are open to considering other options. We are considering adding another skid steer to our fleet, and the CAT dealership's pricing seems competitive. Furthermore, the convenience of having a dealership with a main parts warehouse just 20 minutes away is appealing. We are particularly interested in personal experiences with CAT skid steers. Our requirements include a radial boom, and we are comparing specs with New Holland and Bobcat models. We are in the process of scheduling a demo to further evaluate the CAT skid steer. Any additional insights or opinions would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
If I were in your shoes, I would consider getting a cat (Caterpillar equipment), but viewing a demo could provide more clarity. It's a common observation that farmers rarely settle for just one. How do you plan to coordinate the transition in operation methods across all your staff and machinery? It's interesting that you're opting for a radial lift on a dairy farm, given your preference for vertical lift in your other equipment. Can you explain the reasoning behind this choice?
I mistakenly got my boom names confused, making the pattern change particularly challenging as everyone is accustomed to using foot controls. This adjustment may prove to be quite difficult for users.
Experience the latest CASE or NH machines in action and share your thoughts on their performance. We are eager to get some feedback on these innovative models.
We are subcontracted to a major utility company, where the predominant skid steers used are 185's and 773's. While not my personal preference, these skid steers have proven to be durable and reliable for the demanding tasks they undertake. They are utilized by various crews for tasks such as loading tri-axles, transporting hot top, backfilling trenches, and road sweeping. I was particularly impressed when I witnessed a worker effortlessly lift and carry a 5x10 road plate using a 185 skid steer. Among our fleet, we have a 226B Caterpillar with approximately 1400 hours of use, and a Bobcat 185 with over 2500 hours - both machines have been well-used but remain in good working condition. While the Caterpillar outperforms the Bobcat in terms of speed and agility, the Bobcat excels in breakout force and lifting capacity. It's essential to consider not only specifications but also the skills of the operator when comparing these two skid steers.
After reviewing the options, it appears that the smaller models offer radial lift while the 242b and 252b offer vertical lift. This means that we would require the larger 242b skid steer, which boasts 20 more horsepower than our New Holland machines and can lift 450lbs more. However, I am interested in understanding Caterpillar's lift ratings. Our New Hollands are rated at 1700lbs but can lift over 2000lbs easily. A local farmer purchased an s185 Bobcat and claims it can only lift 1850lbs, while our L170 New Hollands outperform it in lifting capacity. I am seeking insights from personal experiences on whether Cat's rated lifting load is lower than its actual lifting capability. It is my understanding that Cat also offers a counterweight option. Additionally, I have a query regarding the controls - can you switch from Pilot to Case style controls, or is this something that needs to be programmed by the dealer? While I personally prefer the Pilot controls, I am concerned about the learning curve for other employees. I feel that the Case controls might be a better option to avoid accidents, especially when it comes to backing up. It would be beneficial to test out a Cat skid steer on-site for a period to evaluate its performance.
Answer: The lack of CAT skid steers on dairy farms in the area could be attributed to a lack of targeted sales efforts towards farmers and the misconception that CAT skid steers are expensive.
Answer: When comparing skid steers for a dairy farm operation, factors to consider include pricing, dealer proximity, personal experiences with the equipment, specific requirements like a radial boom, and overall specs of the models being considered.
Answer: Competitive pricing from a CAT dealership, coupled with the convenience of having a main parts warehouse located just 20 minutes away, can be appealing factors that influence a dairy farm's decision to consider adding a CAT skid steer to its fleet.
Answer: Scheduling a demo with the CAT dealership to gain firsthand experience with the skid steer, comparing its specs with New Holland and Bobcat models, and seeking out personal experiences from
Join hundreds of satisfied customers who have transformed their maintenance processes.
Sign up today and start optimizing your workflow.